This could also be titled “How I manage to remain a fan of Supernatural, Dr. Who, & Game of Thrones”
"…some fans may find it tempting to argue ‘Well this media is a realistic portrayal of societies like X, Y, Z’ But when you say that sexism and racism and heterosexism and cissexism have to be in the narrative or the story won’t be realistic, what you are saying is that we humans literally cannot recognise ourselves without systemic prejudice, nor can we connect to characters who are not unrepentant bigots. Um, yikes. YIKES, you guys.
I have created this list because, whilst the occasional quote here and there containing problematic statements is easy to write off as ‘words being taken out of context’, seeing all of these quotes, articles, tweets, as well as some meta on major characters written by Moffat together is a little…
Segregated neighborhoods are more likely to be poor, and if you barely earn a living wage, you definitely can’t afford health insurance that would cover preventative care (Thanks Affordable Care Act). The pink ribbon does not help bring awareness to the socioeconomic inequities connected to breast cancer; they commodify the disease and make it “sexy” under the guise of raising awareness.
'Saving the Boobies' is a mantra that gets thrown around a lot this month, but it does not properly address how breast cancer adversely impacts and ends lives. Talking about breasts as if they are an independent entity, as if it’s the breasts that are worth saving as opposed to the life and body they are attached to is not only patriarchal, but also down right sexist. It implies that a woman’s worth is in her breasts, in her sexuality.
This quote is from her essay Saving The Boobies Will Not Save Me on Still Furious and Still Brave. Here she notes that Black women develop breast cancer less often than White women, but are 40% more likely to die. Even when controlled for class, Black women still receive inferior healthcare. This is against the backdrop of a culture that thinks we do not feel pain, need less pain medication, heal faster and are “strong” for the purpose of “enduring” the pain from others.
I had a friend who got breast cancer before 35 and had a double mastectomy. I was glad they saved the HUMAN over “the boobies.” The fragmentation involved in this campaign irritates me. I had a breast cancer scare at age 28. Though my tests came back clean, the period between the tests and no result was incredibly stressful. Worse is how EVERYONE demands joy and heroism and “fuck cancer” and all of this stuff that Black women are already forced to do based on the Strong Black Woman stereotype.
- "But the characters HAVE to be white, it's set in Germany!"
- "They could have easily set it somewhere else, if they cared to do so."
- "The little mermaid can't be black, you can't have a natural redhead who isn't white!"
- "And the story doesn't work if her hair isn't red? Also, I wasn't aware white people COULD have natural fish tails."
- "But it's 18th/19th Century France! There wouldn't be any black people then, and if they were, they'd be slaves!"
- "Tell that to Alexandre Dumas, both the 18th Century French General and his son, the famed 19th Century French author"
- "...If I acknowledge the existence of racism in the things that I enjoy, then I have to confront the possibility that I might sometimes be unconsciously racist, and it's easier for me to pretend racism doesn't exist and blame others for bringing it up than it is for me to unlearn a lifetime's worth of societal conditioning to accept white supremacy as the natural order of things?"
- "There we go."